Wednesday, February 23, 2011

The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro

The Remains of the Day

by Kazuo Ishiguro
published 1989
completed February 2011

I have been wanting to read The Remains of the Day for a very long time.  I finally reserved it at my library and it took five months for it to come.  It happened to arrive when I was in the middle of two readalongs.  I went to renew the book only to discover that someone else had reserved it.  Ahhhh!!  I had two days to read it before leaving on vacation.  I didn't want to wait another five months so I read it very fast, and I wish I hadn't.  Halfway into the book I was still wondering why everyone thought it was so special.  It finally clicked, and I wished I had slowed down.

On the surface, the story is a little stuffy due to the first person narration by a traditional English butler.  He's reflecting on his service over the past several years while traveling through the English countryside.  Sounds boring, right?  It actually isn't.  What it is, is very subtle.  Probably the most subtle book I've ever read.  It really sneaked up on me and by the end, I was in awe of what Ishiguro accomplished.  The story is heartbreaking, but you don't realize it until you put all of the pieces together.  It requires a little reading between the lines, as the cliché goes.  Below is a quote towards the beginning where Steven describes why the English countryside is so remarkable.
And yet, what precisely is this "greatness"?  Just where, or in what, does it lie?  I am quite aware it would take a far wiser head than mine to answer such a question, but if I were forced to hazard a guess, I would say that it is the very lack of obvious drama or spectacle that sets the beauty of our land apart.  What is pertinent is the calmness of that beauty, its sense of restraint.
This description of beauty reminded me so much of Ishiguro's writing.  It's never pretentious and is so restrained that you don't realize it's full impact until it's nearly over.

The first person narration, which is difficult to execute, and the use of an unreliable narrator is genius.  Stevens is different than other unreliable narrators in that he isn't intentionally deceiving you.  Stevens is a butler and he acts the part in every aspect of his life.  I thought it was apt when Miss Kenton asks him why he is always pretending.  He refuses to allow himself to display any emotion so the narration is fact only, no feeling.  By the end, you realize how severely his choices have devastated him.  He feels the regret and tries to change going forward, hence the title.

I'm so sad that I sped through this.  I probably missed so much.  As soon as I finished it, I wanted to start all over and find more subtleties that I might have missed.  I've heard there is a movie adaptation.  Has anyone seen it?  What did you think?

Tuesday, February 22, 2011

War and Peace Readalong--Volume III

I was supposed to publish this post February 12.  Oops!  That's what happens when you throw too much on your plate (my own fault).  I just finished Volume III this morning.  It took me FOREVER!!!  This volume was by far the most tedious.  I love reading about the characters, but the tactical battle stuff was making my eyes glaze over.  Talk of the redoubt (with fleches?) and the position of the left flank.  What?  I don't get it.  I just can't picture it.  I kind of don't care.  I just want to know what happened.

I was interested to see the transformation of some of the characters.  I love Prince Andrei, but the circumstances of the last volume left him bitter.  I was happy to see a bit of a transformation at the end, albeit for a sad reason.  I love that Natasha is maturing.  She's not perfect, but she's not the flighty little girl of the past.  Her compassion on the wounded soldiers at the expense of the Rostov's material possessions made me smile.

It's hard to read about the devastation of the war.  I've always considered the lives lost in the military, but the civilians surrounding the battle were placed in terrifying situations.  How awful that the rich were able to flee, but many of the peasants were left behind.

Tolstoy spent a few chapter philosophizing about war.  It was interesting to learn his perspective.  To him, war is won or lost by the combination of thousands of varied circumstances and thousands of individual wills.  He paints a vivid picture of this in the battle of Borodino.  It shows that Napoleon and Kutuzov had very little control over what was happening.  For all of their planning, what mattered were the choices of thousands of individual soldiers in the thick of the battle.  I'm curious to see how this theme develops in the next volume.

Although it's slow going, I'm glad that I'm making the effort to read War and Peace.  I'll be back on February 28th with my thoughts on Volume IV.  I won't be late next time!

Saturday, February 19, 2011

Oliver Twist--Check In #2

I finally caught up!  Only two days late.  Not over a week late like War and Peace.  Whoops!  Life happens right.

At the end of the last book was the botched robbery.  I was interested to see what happened to poor Oliver.  Luckily, after being ditched by the other robbers, he found favor with a few individuals who nursed him back to health.

I'm still curious as to Oliver's origins.  A new character Rose also has an unknown past, and I wouldn't be surprised if they were somehow connected.  Dickens is know for such coincidences.

I find myself struggling with Oliver Twist.  Like I said, I am curious, but I don't really feel compelled to pick it up.  Much of the humor seems to be absent from the second book.  I miss it.  I'm hoping that the last section will really turn the tide for me.  I really want to love this, but I don't yet.  I'll be back on February 28th with my final thoughts.  See you then!

As a side note, I was delighted to visit Westminster Abbey this past Monday and see where Dickens is buried.  I really wanted to take a picture, but photography is not allowed inside the Abbey.  I'm a rule follower so the best I have are some pictures of the structure from the outside.  I'll post more about my London trip next week.  If you get the chance to visit London someday, make sure you pay a visit to Westminster Abbey.  Poet's Corner is worth the visit.  It made my bookish little heart flutter.

Friday, February 18, 2011

I'm Alive!

I kind of disappeared for a while.  The past two weeks have been crazy!  I got hammered with work and was prepping for a family vacation.  I'm still have 100 pages left to finish of War and Peace and Oliver Twist so I can write my readalong posts that are now late.  Whoops!  No time to read.  Hopefully I'll finish those up and get my posts written this weekend.

Our family just got home from a five day trip to London.  It was my first time, and it was pretty amazing.  I have a few bookish things to share from our trip.  I'm hoping I'll post my thoughts on that early next week about poet's corner at Westminster Abbey and our tour of the reconstruction of Shakespeare's Globe Theatre.

Tuesday, February 8, 2011

Oliver Twist Readalong--Check in #1

I've been wanting to read Oliver Twist for years.  I finally purchased a copy this past November.  This readalong came up at the perfect time.

Oliver Twist was orphaned when his mother died shortly after childbirth and was moved from orphanage, to a workhouse, and to an apprenticeship.  Each place he was treated appallingly.  In a particularly fearful moment, Oliver runs away and makes his way to London.  There he falls in with a band of thieves.

With biting social commentary, it's obvious how Dickens feels about the treatment of the poor during this time period.  Based on his background, having been in a workhouse himself, it's understandable why he feels so strongly.  His insights into humanity are spot on, and he doesn't limit his criticism to the wealthy.  Noah, a charity-boy (slightly above an orphan), was pleased at the fortune of having Oliver around so that he finally had someone to torment, as he had been tormented.  The narrator sarcastically remarks,
This affords charming food for contemplation.  It shows us what a beautiful thing human nature sometimes is, and how impartially the same amiable qualities are developed in the finest lord and the dirtiest charity-boy.
It's angering to read about how the orphans were treated as almost sub-human.  Mr. Bumble even remarks that, "What have paupers to do with soul or spirit?  It's quite enough that we let 'em have live bodies."  Uh!  How awful!

On a lighter note, I love Dickens' humor and sarcasm.  I found it amusing that Mr. Bumble, one of the most despicable characters in his treatment of others, was proudly wearing his buttons displaying the scene of "The Good Samaritan."  Mr. Grimwig created some great comedic moments with his ridiculous, "I'll eat my head!" mantra.

The scene in Mr. Brownlow's study when Oliver is marveling at his books is one of my favorites.  At one point Mr. Brownlow says to Oliver,
You shall read them if you behave well...and you will like that much better than looking at the outsides--that is, in some cases, because there are books of which the backs and the covers are by far the best parts.
To which Oliver replies, "I suppose they are those heavy ones, sir."  I got a chuckle out of that.

I've read a few other Dickens' novels and really loved them.  I'm sort of on the fence about this one.  There are some shining moments.  I'm interested, but not invested (if that even makes sense).  I'm hoping that the next section will really pull me in.

In a bit a randomness, my six-year-old received an assignment this past weekend to choose a famous Victorian person or invention and share it with the class.  When I asked him what he wanted to do he said, "Do you know Charles Dickens?  He's a writer."  He was amazed that we had several of his books at home and that I was currently reading one.  He did his little report yesterday on Dickens' 199th birthday and he thought that was pretty cool.  We discovered that Dickens is buried at Westminster Abbey, and since we're heading to London on holiday next week so we will be sure to make a stop there.

Sunday, January 30, 2011

War and Peace Readalong--Volume II

It's check-in time for the second volume of War and Peace.  I fell behind my reading schedule earlier this week and I was concerned that I wouldn't be able to catch-up.  I had the last 150 pages to read in three days but I ended up almost finishing all of it in one day.  I simply couldn't put it down.

A peace treaty is signed between the sovereign and Napoleon, so the focus shifts to society in Petersburg and Moscow for most of Volume II.  The happenings in society are filled with drama!  There is a duel.  My first ever to read about and it was pretty exciting!  There are also secret engagements, broken promises, an induction into the free masons (random!), thwarted attempts at elopement, and even an attempted suicide.

I'm grateful that I didn't live during this time period where the decision to marry involved so many outside factors.  It's sad that there are couples forced apart because the match is deemed beneath one of the families.  Wealth, and lack thereof, plays an important role in forming marriages.  Those seeking after the wealth feign love and interest in their partner, and that never ends well.  It seems that a marriage based on mutual love is very rare.

So many loose ends right now.  Most of the marriageable individuals fates are still dangling and I'm curious to see how it all plays out.  Tolstoy is sure filling this novel with twists and turns that I don't always see coming.  Off to start Volume III!

On a completely unrelated note, I finished The Corrections last week and I came across a passage that made me chuckle.  One of the characters was taking a lunch break at work and she happened to be reading War and Peace.  She mentioned that she was too embarrassed to read it in public for fear of looking pretentious, so she sat and stared at the sky instead.  I can relate.  Also, it is heavy!

The Corrections by Jonathan Franzen

The Corrections

by Jonathan Franzen
published 2001
completed January 2011

I was really hesitant to pick up The Corrections.  Until the controversy over Jonathan Franzen appearing on the cover of Time, I knew nothing about it.  I completely missed the debacle in 2001 over its selection for Oprah's Book Club.  I'm not too surprised since I'm not an Oprah watcher, and I was in the midst of a  grad school vortex.  Sadly, knowing that Jonathan Franzen snubbed Oprah kind of piqued my interest enough for me to pick it up.  I'm so glad that I did.  It was brilliant.

Alfred and Enid Lambert have three adult children--Chip, Gary, and Denise--who have fled their Midwestern home in St. Jude (patron saint of lost causes) and have ventured to the East Coast.  With Alfred deteriorating rapidly from Parkinson's Disease, Enid wants the family to gather for one last Christmas in St. Jude.

I cannot do this book justice.  Every time I sat down to write this I couldn't come up with a coherent thought.  Please forgive me if this becomes a bit rambling.  I started out hating every single character in this book.  We meet them all surrounding the initial talks of gathering for Christmas while the parents are in New York on their way to board a cruise ship.  Each chapter focuses on one of the children and Franzen slowly shares their life experiences that make them who they are at present.  He never tries to justify his characters actions or garner sympathy for them.  He presents facts so that you can understand the characters.

The Lambert Family is about as dysfunction as families get.  It is bad.  On the surface they are congenial, but underneath is festering bitterness, hatred, and blaming.  There are a number of unique uses of the word corrections throughout the novel.  The main reason is that it is set during the stock market boom and ends when the market corrects itself in the late nineties.  Aside from that, it also focuses on the corrections that each character feels they need to make-up for their childhood.  Each child feels scarred in some way by their upbringing, but by the end, they finally come to see their parents and childhood in a better light.

What happens in The Corrections is tragic, but it never feels that way.  Without the humor, The Corrections would have been unbearable.  Chip has a realization towards the end of the book that a script he has been working on should be "tragedy rewritten as a farce."  After this realization
"he bore down with a mental read pencil on his mental reconstruction of these pages, made a little trim here, added emphasis or hyperbole there, and in his mind the scenes became what they'd wanted to be all along: ridiculous." 
I believe Franzen is speaking a little about himself here and his intention to push The Corrections to the point of a farce.  It was a brilliant move.  Toward the end of the book, Chip is trying to make his way to St. Jude for Christmas and is robbed by rogue police in a foreign country that is in upheaval.  During which the following happens.
Chip's sphincter had meanwhile dilated to the degree of unconditional surrender.  It seemed very important to contain himself, however, and so he stood in his socks and underwear and pressed his butt cheeks together as well as he could with his shaking hands.  Pressed and pressed and fought the spasms manually.  He didn't care how ridiculous he looked.
Chip is possibly about to die and not make it back to see his parents for Christmas, but I am laughing out loud because of this ludicrous situation.  Brilliant Mr. Franzen.  Brilliant.

There isn't a lot of plot to The Corrections.  The focus is on the characters.  By the end, I think what I gathered from this is that family really matters.  I could relate to the Lambert children in that used to look back on my childhood with disdain.  I don't agree with some of the choices my parents made in raising me.  I want different for my children, but I've learned to love and respect my parents.  They did the best they could, and I think the Lambert children also came to that conclusion.  The Lambert children ran far away as adults, but they slowly made their way back, not literally, but at least in their hearts.  Our families are never going to be perfect, but they are a part of us regardless.

This book has been so over-hyped that I don't intend to change anyone's mind about it.  I loved it, but even saying that, I can see how this book is disliked by so many.  If you're looking for fast-paced, this is not that kind of book.  It's slow and meandering at times, but I was happy with the journey and the eventual destination.  I feel obligated to warn that there is a generous helping of graphic language and sex.  It wasn't gratuitous and seemed necessary to the understanding of the characters.  I'm sorry this is so long!  I could gush about it all day.  I'm really looking forward to picking up Freedom when I get a chance.